|
BucFan40, I hope you dont think 17 TD's over 4 years is good. If you combine special teams and WR play.
If some of those are coming on special teams, i'm fine with it. We need a returner. Spurlock broke the curse but he is not a very good returner.
What makes it even worse is it was at a D-1AA school.
So did Flacco. So did Tony Romo. So did T.O. Coming from a small school doesn't matter.
Manningham is not worth a pick? When you compare Numbers, and numbers dont lie, Manningham played against better comp and bottom line he has better numbers! He had 10 more TD's than Jackson. Who cares if his wonderlick test was bad, he is not a player who gets in trouble, and puts up numbers. If he is scoreing TD's what are you going to say "who cares if he scores because he is stupid". If he can play ball who cares. So what if he got shut out of one half of a football game, his stats are better
Numbers do lie. If a DE has a sack in a game, it doesn't mean he played great. It means he got off the ball quick. Playing against good competition doesn't matter all that much. Who played against better competition, t.o. or jaquez green? The jackson pick was based more on his return ability. In gruden's offense, you need to be smart and obviously manningham is not. He does get in trouble. He told NFL teams that he doesnt and has never failed a drug test and the next day, he fails one. He won't score in the NFL. He's too slow, small, and well, too dumb to function in Gruden's offense. I care that he got shut down by a freshman, that until that year, had never played corner. Big-time receivers do not get shut down by freshman corners. I can't even begin to tell you how bad of a pick that would have been.
Bucs fans do we really want to draft another florida WR? Jacquez Green, reidel Anthony, both who were bust's.
Here's the difference. Caldwell played in Zook's pro-style offense and was successful. He played in Meyer's offense wich is really the West Coast system out of the shot-gun and with a running qb. They run crosses and stuff like that. He was again, successful in that. He's Florida's leading receiver all-time. He only played in about 3/4 of his games which presents a concern but most of the missed games were because of a broken leg. Anyway, he only played in about 3/4 of his games and still put up great numbers. He is also a bigger build and can therefore put some weight on. He's still on the board and runs a 4.29. manningham runs a 4.6 i think thats about .3 better. If the bucs draft mannigham, i'm selling my tickets
|
