Crosby or Ovechkin?

Brendan Morrow in a ridicoulously close one.

Derek Boogaard or Chris Simon?

Derek Boogaard because Chris Simon has turned into one of the dirtiest hockey players around and I sure wouldn't want him on my team. 

Dustin Penner or Marek Svatos?

Endstrom.

This is getting old. People keep repeating the same players from this era. Hockey has been around for 100 years!

Guy Lafleur or Jari Kurri?

woops, I was on the wrong page.

Penner!

I wasn't sure if we were limited to players now, but next time I'll choose some old time hockey players.

Guy Lafleur

Jean Beliveau or Stan Mikita?

I'll take Stan the man!!  More grit!

Pat LaFantaine or Bernie Nicholls?

Hextal. Emery shouldn't even be in the same sentence. Plus he's a head case!!

Andy Moog or Pete Peeters?